What is the Right of First Refusal in Child Custody

Is the Right of First Refusal Right for Your Family?

When you’re navigating the complexities of separation and coparenting, every decision feels monumental, and the legal terms can be overwhelming. One concept you might encounter is the “right of first refusal” in child custody. This is an arrangement where if one parent needs childcare during their scheduled time, they must first offer that time to the other parent before seeking outside help. It sounds fair on the surface, but like many things in coparenting, the reality can be more complicated.

The goal of any good coparenting plan is to create a stable, peaceful environment where your children can thrive. So, when considering the right of first refusal, let’s take a moment to pause and ask a simple, yet powerful, question: Is this truly in the best interest of our children?

The Appeal of the Right of First Refusal

There are times when the right of first refusal can be a helpful tool. For very young children, especially infants, frequent contact with both parents is crucial for building a strong bond. If one parent has limited custodial time, perhaps due to a challenging work schedule or because the child is still breastfeeding, a right of first refusal, even for just a few hours, can provide valuable opportunities for them to connect. This frequent, repeated contact helps strengthen their relationship, which is essential as the child grows and parenting time increases.

It can also be a sensible option if you have concerns about the other parent’s support system. If you believe your child might be left with people you can’t trust, or if you know the other parent has emotional regulation challenges and needs breaks to recharge, the right of first refusal can be a way to ensure your child’s well-being and safety.

When It Might Cause More Harm Than Good

While the right of first refusal can be beneficial in specific situations, it often creates more problems than it solves. The key is to consider the impact from your child’s perspective, not just your own desire for more time.

One of the biggest issues is that the right of first refusal can prevent children from ever feeling truly settled. Children, like adults, need downtime and a sense of routine. Imagine you’re a child who has just started to relax and feel at home, reading a book, playing a game with a stepsibling, or simply snuggling up in bed, only to be disrupted every few hours because a parent needs to exercise their right of first refusal. This constant back-and-forth can be incredibly unsettling and prevent them from feeling safe and secure in either home.

This constant movement also increases a child’s exposure to parental conflict. Parents who are rigid about the right of first refusal are often already in high-conflict situations. The back-and-forth communication, the strict adherence to rules, and the potential for perceived violations can lead to constant arguments and tension, all of which your child can sense. We know that exposing children to ongoing parental conflict is harmful to their well-being.

Another unintended consequence is that it can turn children into “little spies.” When parents are always trying to monitor the other’s activities, children get caught in the middle. They may be asked questions like, “What was your mom doing?” or “Who was watching you?” This puts them in a difficult position, creating loyalty conflicts and making them feel like they have to gather intelligence or lie to avoid getting a parent in trouble. This is an immense and unfair burden to place on a child.

Finally, the right of first refusal can hinder a child’s natural growth and development. A child’s job is to individuate – to learn, grow, and become their own person. Part of this process involves expanding their social circle and building relationships with other trusted adults, like grandparents, aunts, uncles, or stepparents. If a child is constantly being “rescued” from these opportunities, they lose out on valuable interactions that help them learn about themselves and the world around them.

Before implementing or exercising the right of first refusal, take a moment to reflect. Is your motivation rooted in your child’s needs or your own desire to have more time with them? We all want more time with our kids – that’s a normal, loving emotion. But it’s important to be honest about whether your actions are truly serving their best interests. Would your child enjoy a quiet afternoon at the other parent’s house, perhaps playing with a stepsibling or an aunt, more than they would enjoy yet another transition?

The truth is, a child’s time is their own. It’s not a commodity to be claimed or a battle to be won. Their lives and needs are evolving, and sometimes that means they need time to grow, learn, and be with other people. Allowing this helps them become secure, confident individuals with a broad social network.

To further explore these topics and find more guidance on navigating custody issues, listen to our podcasts: